You Can’t Imagine the Future Alone
On belonging, calling, and why imagination fails in isolation
On belonging, calling, and why imagination fails in isolation
I recently finished the book Imaginable: How to Create a Hopeful Future by Jane McGonigal. It’s not a religious book, but it names something I see all the time in ministry—and frankly, in my own life.
The book is about imagination. Not in a vague or inspirational sense, but as a discipline. McGonigal argues that our ability to picture a different future—clearly, concretely—is one of the most important drivers of change.
That part wasn’t new to me.
What was new, or at least what I needed to be reminded of, was this:
imagination doesn’t fail because we lack ideas. It fails because we lack the right people.
That hits, doesn’t it…
McGonigal describes four ways we relate to the future: calling, belonging, hope, and power.
Most of us, especially in ministry, tend to fixate on calling.
We ask:
What is God asking me to do?
What problem am I meant to address?
What future am I supposed to help create?
And for many pastors and leaders, those questions are not abstract. The challenges are real, visible, and pressing.
But there’s a second dimension that often goes unnoticed:
belonging.
Belonging, in McGonigal’s framework, is about whether you are connected to others who see the same future you do—who are working toward it, who recognize the problem, who share the urgency.
Without that, something subtle but significant begins to happen.
You can have clarity of calling and still feel disconnected from the future.
You start to sense that others aren’t as invested.
That the change you see isn’t shared.
That the work ahead is yours alone to carry.
And over time, that gap creates strain. It creates fatigue. It creates exhaustion.
Not because the calling isn’t real.
But because it isn’t held in common.
There’s no one to walk alongside as you take that journey of faith.
What struck me most is how practical her conclusion is.
If your sense of calling outpaces your sense of belonging, you have a few options:
Begin to form that community yourself
Find others already working on the problem
Or Step into a different community that recognizes the work
Even one or two people aligned around the same future can change your sense of what’s possible.
Trust me on that.
But also, consider that it raises a harder question—not about imagination, but about reality:
What happens when your calling outgrows your community?
I don’t think the answer is to work harder or wait longer.
I think it has something to do with finding the right people.
That’s what we’re trying to do here. Stay Tuned…
If you are serving in a church sustained more by memory than momentum, this conversation is for you.
Substack Seminary exists to help pastors and church leaders think clearly about capacity, sustainability, and leadership in a post-growth church.
If you’re tired of being told that bigger is the only faithful option, and you want language and frameworks for leading well within real limits, this is the space for you.
Join us.